How would you feel if your favourite movie character was supposed to be portrayed by someone else…only that…it wasn’t?
A lot of movie roles may seem like they were created for a handful of famous celebrities but that isn’t always the case. In fact, there are quite a few famous characters who had someone else in mind. Unfortunately, the superstars had to turn down the offer due to a busy schedule, over qualification (due to age) and various other reasons.
Would you feel devastated — or relieved — that the particular roles went to someone else instead?
1) Edward Cullen from Twilight
Before Robert Pattinson was cast for the role of Edward, Twilight author Stephenie Meyer clearly spoke out that this role was the “most difficult character to cast” but also the one she was “most passionately decided upon”.
She was, in fact, devastated when Henry Cavill could not perform the role as he was too old to be able to realistically play the role (Cavill was 24 while Pattinson was 22). Meyer admitted to feeling under-whelmed upon seeing a photo of Pattinson but saw the sparks fly when they had a love scene with co-star Kristen Stewart during auditions.
2) Bella from Twilight
In the same blog post where Stephenie Meyer announced who she wanted to play as Edward Cullen, she also announced that she wanted Emily to play the part of Bella Swan in the trilogy. She was asked to audition for the role but because she had just finished filming The Uninvited, she decided to take a break instead of signing herself up for a trilogy.
3) Vivianne from Pretty Woman
Director Gary Marshall initially wanted Karen Allen for the role of Vivian Ward. But, when she turned it down, they decided to have Molly Ringwald take it. Unfortunately, Ringwald felt uncomfortable playing a sex worker. Winona Ryder and Jennifer Connelly also auditioned but were dismissed because they were “too young” for the role. When other actresses such as Mary Steenburgen, Diane Lane, Michelle Pfeiffer, Daryl Hannah, Valeria Golino, Jennifer Jason Leigh turned down the role, the then-unknown 21-year-old Julia Roberts was cast for the role and made a superstar out of her.
4) Agent Scully from The X Files
The producers of The X-Files wanted a bustier, taller and leggier female actress to play the role of Agent Scully. Gillian said that at the beginning, nobody really trusted that she could no anything as she has no body of work behind her. Somehow, franchise creator Chris Carter saw something in her and stuck with her instead.
4) Walter White in Breaking Bad
As much as I really like Matthew, no one could of beat Bryan Cranston — he played the role so beautifully. Cranston was Director Vince Gilligan’s first choice but the studio executives were not convinced as they had only seen Cranston playing the doodling father in ‘Malcolm in the Middle’. Breaking Bad is regarded as the greatest TV show of all time – and I would agree!
5) James Bond in Casino Royale
A lot of famous actors have turned down the role as the popular James Bond. Hugh was apparently unsatisfied with the direction towards which the producers wanted the characters to take so he stayed true to himself and declined the offer.
6) Clarice Starling in The Silence of the Lambs
Director Jonathan Demme’s ideal actress for the role was Michelle Pfeiffer. Unfortunately, she had to turn it down because she was turned off by the amount of violence and gore in the film — thus the role went to Jodie Foster.
7) Indiana Jones in Indiana Jones
Tom Selleck was huge at the time of casting Indiana Jones and producers were banking on the popularity to get Indiana Jones off to a huge start. However, Selleck had to choose: Magnum PI or Indiana. Thank goodness he chose right because Harrison Ford was made for that role!
8) Ferris Bueller in Ferris Bueller’s Day Off
Things may have been different had Johnny Depp accepted the part of Ferris. In a later interview, he said that he couldn’t accept the role due to conflicting schedules thus Matthew Broderick — who was exceptional, by the way — was cast instead.
9) Billy Flynn in Chicago
Hugh Jackman turned down yet another role as Billy Flynn in the movie musical Chicago. He stated that he was too young at that time for the role so Richard Gere took on the job instead.
10) Christian Grey in 50 Shades of Grey
Well, even Charlie wasn’t the producers’ first choice. An actor called Garrett Hedlund was first picked but was dropped as there was a ‘lack of connection’ with his character. Charlie Hunnam, on the other hand, had to drop out due to scheduling issues.
11) Tony Soprano in The Sopranos
It was probably Ray Liotta’s role as the gangster Henry Hill in Goodfellas that made The Sopranos‘ producers consider him for the role of Tony Soprano. Unfortunately, Liotta wanted to focus on movies and signing up for the series would mean at least a 2-year commitment on his part. Things did eventually work out great and James Gandolfini did an amazing job with it.